Wednesday, December 29, 2021

CDC MMWR: Investigation of a SARS-CoV-2 Omicron Variant Cluster — Nebraska, Nov–Dec 2021



#16,466

Although we only got our first look at a new, emerging COVID variant (now dubbed Omicron) from South Africa 5 weeks ago (see Nov 25th South African NICD Statement On B.1.1.529 Variant), we now know this highly transmissible virus had already embarked on its world tour.

While there are reports suggesting Omicron may produce milder illness than Delta, its increased  transmissibility and heightened ability to evade prior immunity - either from vaccination or previous infection - more than makes up for any reduced pathogenicity. 

Yesterday the CDC's MMWR published an Early Release report on the earliest known importation of Omicron into the United States by a traveler from Nigeria who arrived on Nov 23th, and its subsequent spread to the index cases' 5 close contacts.  

While this report covers just one small cluster (n=6) of Omicron cases, it suggests that incubation times for Omicron may be lower than we've seen previously with COVID, and that the clinical course of their illness was `similar to or milder than' what has previously been reported among vaccinated and/or previously infected individuals infected with Delta. 

They did note that:

The unvaccinated patient without a previous COVID-19 diagnosis experienced cough, joint pain, congestion, fever, and chills.

None of the five, however, became ill enough to be hospitalized. 

Whether this cluster is representative of Omicron's impact on a wider scale remains to be seen, but it does generally correspond to some of the anecdotal reports we are hearing; rapid onset of symptoms, vaccine breakthroughs and reinfections being common, and milder symptoms among the vaccinated. 

First a link, and excerpts from this MMWR Early Release, after which I'll return with a postscript. 
Investigation of a SARS-CoV-2 B.1.1.529 (Omicron) Variant Cluster — Nebraska, November–December 2021

Early Release / December 28, 2021 / 70

Lauren Jansen, MD1,2; Bryan Tegomoh, MD1,3; Kate Lange4; Kimberly Showalter4; Jon Figliomeni, MHA1; Baha Abdalhamid, MD, PhD5; Peter C. Iwen, PhD5; Joseph Fauver, PhD6; Bryan Buss, DVM1,7; Matthew Donahue, MD1

PDF pdf icon[234K]


The B.1.1.529 (Omicron) variant of SARS-CoV-2 (the virus that causes COVID-19) was first detected in specimens collected on November 11, 2021, in Botswana and on November 14 in South Africa;* the first confirmed case of Omicron in the United States was identified in California on December 1, 2021 (1). On November 29, the Nebraska Department of Health and Human Services was notified of six probable cases† of COVID-19 in one household, including one case in a man aged 48 years (the index patient) who had recently returned from Nigeria.
Given the patient’s travel history, Omicron infection was suspected. Specimens from all six persons in the household tested positive for SARS-CoV-2 by reverse transcription–polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) testing on December 1, and the following day genomic sequencing by the Nebraska Public Health Laboratory identified an identical Omicron genotype from each specimen (Figure). Phylogenetic analysis was conducted to determine if this cluster represented an independent introduction of Omicron into the United States, and a detailed epidemiologic investigation was conducted. This activity was reviewed by CDC and was conducted consistent with applicable federal law and CDC policy.§

The index patient, who was unvaccinated, had a history of domestically acquired symptomatic SARS-CoV-2 infection confirmed by RT-PCR a year prior in November 2020. He reported unmasked close contact¶ with a masked, coughing person on November 20, 2021, during an international conference in Nigeria, which included attendees from multiple African countries. Before his return trip to the United States, he completed required pretravel testing with receipt of a negative antigen test result on November 21.
Upon his return on November 23, while still asymptomatic, he had unmasked close contact with five household contacts. One household contact was fully vaccinated** (second Pfizer-BioNTech vaccine dose received in August 2021) and had previous symptomatic COVID-19 (RT-PCR confirmed in November 2020), three were unvaccinated and had previous symptomatic COVID-19 (RT-PCR confirmed in November 2020), and one was unvaccinated and had mild upper respiratory symptoms in November 2020, just before illness onset in the other household members, but received a negative SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR test result at that time. No household members reported underlying medical conditions or immunocompromising conditions known to increase the risk for severe COVID-19 or diminish response to vaccination.††

On November 24, 2021, the index patient experienced symptoms consistent with COVID-19§§ and initially received a positive SARS-CoV-2 antigen test result from a local medical center on November 26. All six household members (median age = 18.5 years; range = 11–48 years) experienced symptom onset during November 24–26; median interval between earliest possible exposure to the index patient and symptom onset was 73 hours (range = 33–75 hours). The index patient and the four household contacts with previous confirmed infections described the symptoms and severity of their recent COVID-19 infection as being similar to or milder than those during their first infection.
The five reinfected patients experienced fewer current symptoms, including loss of taste (none), loss of smell (none), and subjective fever (two), compared with symptoms reported during their first infections (four, four, and four, respectively). The unvaccinated patient without a previous COVID-19 diagnosis experienced cough, joint pain, congestion, fever, and chills. None required hospitalization for either their first or second infections. Twelve close community contacts of the family were identified. Four consented to testing for SARS-CoV-2 (median of 10.5 days postexposure; range = 10–11 days); specimens from these four close contacts tested negative.

Epidemiologic and clinical features of Omicron infection are still being described. Observations from this investigation, which included one patient who experienced reinfection¶¶ after having been fully vaccinated, four patients who experienced reinfection, and one who experienced their first infection, suggest a shorter incubation period and a clinical syndrome similar to or milder than that associated with previously described variants in persons who have been vaccinated or previously infected, and add to existing evidence suggesting an increased potential for reinfection.*** Whereas the median SARS-CoV-2 incubation period has been described as ≥5 days (2,3), and closer to 4 days for the SARS-CoV-2 B.1.617.2 (Delta) variant,††† the median incubation period§§§ observed in this cluster was approximately 3 days.
Although few clinical descriptions of Omicron infections are available, mild illness among vaccinated patients has been reported (4). It is unknown whether the mild clinical syndromes or differing symptom descriptions are a result of existing immunity or altered clinical features associated with Omicron infection. The five reinfections, including one after full vaccination, might be explained by waning immunity, the potential for partial immune evasion by Omicron, or both. Conclusions drawn from these observations are limited by small sample size. More data will be needed to fully understand the epidemiology of the Omicron variant.

Travel history of the index patient and phylogenetic analysis of the secondary cases indicate an international introduction of the Omicron variant, consistent with other early cases identified in the United States (1). The recent emergence of Omicron, which is now projected to be the dominant variant in the United States,¶¶¶ reinforces the importance of vaccination, in coordination with other prevention strategies (e.g., masking and physical distancing), to protect people from COVID-19, slow transmission, and reduce the likelihood of new variants emerging. In addition, the rapid identification and epidemiologic characterization of this cluster underscore the importance of robust and timely genomic surveillance to detect and respond to emerging SARS-CoV-2 variants of concern.


Although this report adds weight to the notion that Omicron may produce a milder course of illness (on average) than Delta - there remain large gaps in our knowledge - and there are enough `bad' things about Omicron (enhanced vaccine and immune escape, greatly increased transmissibility, etc.) to make it a formidable foe. 

But since it is such short supply, we'll take whatever `good' news we can get.