Despite its portrayal in popular culture, there are very few `Eureka!' moments in scientific discovery, where a brilliant scientist uncovers (or stumbles upon) some universal truth. Instead research is incremental - often taking years or decades and involving many teams working together or separately across the globe, first verifying, then building on each other's work.
This is why I feature so many studies in this blog, even those that don't appear to provide firm conclusions. Because they provide a road map - not only of where we are going - but where we have been along the discovery trail.Over the years we've looked at a number of research projects delving into a suspected link between prenatal fever and a variety of neurological problems, including autism spectrum disorder (ASD).
- A study from 2008 (Structural brain alterations in schizophrenia following fetal exposure to the inflammatory cytokine interleukin-8 Ellman et al.) suggested that prenatal exposure to a type of protein - (proinflammatory cytokines, specifically interleukin-8) – produced by the body during viral infections, that can lead (in rare cases) to brain abnormalities.
- In 2012 research by a team at UC Davis found that fever (from any cause) during pregnancy more than doubled the odds of having a child with autism or developmental delays (see Is Maternal Influenza or Fever During Pregnancy Associated with Autism or Developmental Delays? Results from the CHARGE (CHildhood Autism Risks from Genetics and Environment) Study Zerbo et al.)
- In November of 2012, in Of Pregnancy, Flu & Autism, we saw a study that found a twofold increase in autism among children with prenatal influenza exposure, and a threefold increase in autism among children with prolonged prenatal fever exposure
- And in May, 2013 we looked at a JAMA Psychiatry report that linked bipolar disorder (BD) to influenza exposure while still in the womb (see Pregnancy, Influenza, & Bipolar Disorder In Offspring).
To this cannon of work, we can add a new study - published today in Molecular Psychiatry - that adds additional weight to the suspected link between prenatal fever and ASD. Specifically, maternal fever in the 2nd trimester was linked to a 40% increased risk of autism.First an excerpt from the (open access) study, followed by some excerpts from the press release from Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health. After that, I'll return with a bit more.
Molecular Psychiatry advance online publication 13 June 2017; doi: 10.1038/mp.2017.119
Prenatal fever and autism risk
M Hornig1,2, M A Bresnahan2,3, X Che1, A F Schultz1, J E Ukaigwe1, M L Eddy1, D Hirtz4, N Gunnes5, K K Lie5, P Magnus5, S Mjaaland5, T Reichborn-Kjennerud5,6, S Schjølberg5, A-S Øyen5,7, B Levin8, E S Susser2,3, C Stoltenberg5,9 and W I Lipkin1,2,10
Correspondence: Dr M Hornig, Center for Infection and Immunity, Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University, 722 West 168th Street, 17th Floor, New York, NY 10032, USA. E-mail: email@example.com
Received 25 April 2016; Revised 24 March 2017; Accepted 19 April 2017
Advance online publication 13 June 2017
Some studies suggest that prenatal infection increases risk of autism spectrum disorders (ASDs). This study was undertaken in a prospective cohort in Norway to examine whether we could find evidence to support an association of the prenatal occurrence of fever, a common manifestation of infection, with ASD risk.
Prospective questionnaires provided maternal exposure data; case status was established from clinical assessments and registry linkages. In a large, prospectively ascertained cohort of pregnant mothers and their offspring, we examined infants born greater than or equal to32 weeks for associations between fever exposure in each trimester and ASD risk using logistic regression.
Maternal exposure to second-trimester fever was associated with increased ASD risk, adjusting for presence of fever in other trimesters and confounders (adjusted odds ratio (aOR), 1.40; 95% confidence interval, 1.09–1.79), with a similar, but nonsignificant, point estimate in the first trimester. Risk increased markedly with exposure to three or more fever episodes after 12 weeks' gestation (aOR, 3.12; 1.28–7.63).
ASD risk appears to increase with maternal fever, particularly in the second trimester. Risk magnified dose dependently with exposure to multiple fevers after 12 weeks' gestation. Our findings support a role for gestational maternal infection and innate immune responses to infection in the pathogenesis of at least some cases of ASD.
To our knowledge, there are no other prospective studies examining maternally reported use of antipyretics for fever and ASD. A retrospective study reporting an association of first- and second-trimester fever with increased ASD risk found that acetaminophen and NSAIDs mitigated fever-associated risks.21 Data were not separately reported for antipyretics with and without anti-inflammatory potential. Here we found only small risk reduction with use of acetaminophen for fever in conjunction with a small increase in risk among febrile women who did not take acetaminophen. In contrast, none of the women with offspring later diagnosed with ASD used ibuprofen for fever in pregnancy, although these findings must be interpreted with extreme caution, given the low overall frequency of ibuprofen use in this population.(SNIP)
Our findings support the hypothesis that fever and associated immune disturbances are implicated in a subset of ASD cases. Although acetaminophen was associated with a small decrease in risk in the context of fever, prior studies reporting ablation of fever-associated risk with use of a diverse range of medications with antipyretic properties, including NSAIDs as well as acetaminophen—along with our own limited data on ibuprofen—suggest that the choice of antipyretic warrants scrutiny.
We have not addressed microbial causes of maternal fever and immune activation. Accordingly, future work should focus on identifying and preventing prenatal infections and inflammatory responses that may contribute to ASD pathogenesis.(Continue . . . . )
Prenatal exposure to maternal fever during the second trimester raised odds of autism spectrum disorder by 40 percent
Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health
Fever during pregnancy may raise the risk for autism spectrum disorder (ASD) in the child, according to a study led by scientists at the Center for Infection and Immunity (CII) at Columbia University's Mailman School of Public Health. The effect was most pronounced in the second trimester, raising odds for ASD by 40 percent. Risk of an ASD was increased by over 300 percent for the children of women reporting three or more fevers after the twelfth week of pregnancy.
The study is the most robust to date to explore the risk of ASD associated with fevers across the entire span of pregnancy, and of the capacity of two different types of commonly used anti-fever medications--acetaminophen and ibuprofen--to address that risk.
Risks were minimally mitigated among the children of women taking acetaminophen for fever in the second trimester. Although there were no cases of ASD among children of mothers who took ibuprofen, a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug, researchers could not ascertain whether risk was mitigated due to the extremely small number of women using this particular drug for fever. Results of the study appear in the journal Molecular Psychiatry.(Continue . . . )
While none of this proves causality, the link between prenatal fever and variety of congenital brain disorders continues to grow.
Unfortunately, the obvious `solution' - to recommend antipyretics for pregnant women with fever - isn't without its own downsides. In recent years the use of NSAIDs and acetaminophen have been linked to a possible increased risks of other congenital complications.In 2015, the FDA issued this Drug Safety announcement:
FDA Drug Safety Communication: FDA has reviewed possible risks of pain medicine use during pregnancy
[ 1-9-2015 ]
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is aware of and understands the concerns arising from recent reports questioning the safety of prescription and over-the-counter (OTC) pain medicines when used during pregnancy. As a result, we evaluated research studies published in the medical literature and determined they are too limited to make any recommendations based on these studies at this time. Because of this uncertainty, the use of pain medicines during pregnancy should be carefully considered. We urge pregnant women to always discuss all medicines with their health care professionals before using them.
Severe and persistent pain that is not effectively treated during pregnancy can result in depression, anxiety, and high blood pressure in the mother.1 Medicines including nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), opioids, and acetaminophen can help treat severe and persistent pain. However, it is important to carefully weigh the benefits and risks of using prescription and OTC pain medicines during pregnancy.
The published studies we reviewed reported on the potential risks associated with the following three types of pain medicines used during pregnancy (see Data Summary section for more information about these studies):
We found all of the studies we reviewed to have potential limitations in their designs; sometimes the accumulated studies on a topic contained conflicting results that prevented us from drawing reliable conclusions. As a result, our recommendations on how pain medicines are used during pregnancy will remain the same at this time.
- Prescription NSAIDs and the risk of miscarriage in the first half of pregnancy.2-6 Examples of prescription NSAIDs include ibuprofen, naproxen, diclofenac, and celecoxib.
- Opioids, which are available only by prescription, and the risk of birth defects of the brain, spine, or spinal cord in babies born to women who took these products during the first trimester of pregnancy.7, 8 Examples of opioids include oxycodone, hydrocodone, hydromorphone, morphine, and codeine.
- Acetaminophen in both OTC and prescription products and the risk of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in children born to women who took this medicine at any time during pregnancy.9 Acetaminophen is a common pain reducer and fever reducer found in hundreds of medicines including those used for colds, flu, allergies, and sleep.
Pregnant women should always consult with their health care professional before taking any prescription or OTC medicine. Women taking pain medicines who are considering becoming pregnant should also consult with their health care professionals to discuss the risks and benefits of pain medicine use. Health care professionals should continue to follow the recommendations in the drug labels when prescribing pain medicines to pregnant patients.
We will continue to monitor and evaluate the use of pain medicines during pregnancy and will update the public as new safety information becomes available.
As stated above, the jury is still out on just how much of an increased risk (if any) these medications present during pregnancy. But it is pretty much a given that there is no such thing as drug that is 100% safe for 100% of the population 100% of the time.
As with all medicines, there is always a trade off; risk vs. reward.Since prevention is always better than a cure, finding ways to prevent maternal fevers is a priority, which is one of the big reasons the CDC, the WHO, and other public health promote the seasonal flu vaccination of pregnant women.
Most years, the vaccine provides moderate protection against circulating flu strains, but in the event a pregnant woman becomes infected, studies also show the Benefits Of Early Use of Influenza Antivirals In Pregnancy.
We're still a long way from understanding the causes of ASD, and preventing it. But with each new study, we are incrementally drawing closer to those goals.