Wednesday, December 08, 2021

UK Revised Risk Assessment On COVID Omicron (B.1.1.529)


#16,400

In a follow up to an earlier post today (see UK Reportedly Close To Enacting `Plan B' For COVID), Prime Minister Boris Johnson has confirmed in an afternoon news conference that the UK will implement Plan `B' due to the spread of the Omicron variant (see Sky News COVID-19: Boris Johnson announces Plan B restrictions). 

This announcement comes as the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) has released a new Risk Assessment on Omicron, which confirms this new variant is spreading faster than Delta and is likely to become the dominant strain in the UK in a matter of weeks. 

First the revised risk assessment I've posted the graphic, and reproduced the text, for easy reading. The big unknown remains the severity of infection, compared to other variants. 

Growth advantage  

Omicron is displaying a growth advantage over Delta This assessment is based on analysis of UK data showing increased household transmission risk, increased secondary attack rates and increased growth rates compared to Delta. Omicron is likely to outcompete Delta in the UK and predominate. The observed growth advantage may be due to immune evasion or transmissibility. It is most plausible that it is a combination of both. The current growth rate implies either a substantial change in one parameter or at least moderate change in both (for example if transmissibility is similar to Delta, immune evasion must be substantial). 

Transmissibility  

Omicron is at least as transmissible as Delta Increased transmissibility compared to Delta is biologically plausible with the presence of furin cleavage site and nucleocapsid changes associated in vitro with advantages for replication, as well as extensive changes to the RBD. Structural modelling suggests that the mutations present may increase human ACE2 binding affinity to a much greater extent than that seen for any other variant. However, there is as yet no demonstration of transmissibility as distinct from other contributors to growth advantage.  

Immune evasion (including natural and vaccine derived immunity)

Omicron displays a reduction in immune protection against infection (no data regarding severe disease) Based on experience with other variants, laboratory data on individual mutations, and structural modelling, the mutations present are very likely to reduce antibody binding and include changes in all 4 neutralising antibody binding sites in the RBD and also in antigenic sites in the spike N terminal domain. New published neutralisation studies are being assessed. T cell epitope data are awaited. Whilst there are insufficient data to quantify either vaccine effectiveness or risk of reinfection in the UK, the observed growth, case distribution and early analyses in both SA and the UK are consistent with some loss of immune protection against infection. There are insufficient data to make any assessment of protection against severe disease.  

Infection severity 

There are insufficient data to assess severity, which is expected in the early period of emergence of a new variant

In their latest update on UK Variants, the UKHSA reports:


UKHSA publishes update on Omicron risk assessment, S gene target failure and local case numbers

The assessment suggests that Omicron is displaying a significant growth advantage over Delta, meaning that it is likely to outcompete Delta in the UK and become the dominant variant.

This assessment is based on analysis of UK data showing increased household transmission risk, increased secondary attack rates (such as the chance of each case infecting another individual) and increased growth rates compared to Delta.

If the growth rate and doubling time continue at the rate we have seen in the last 2 weeks, we expect to see at least 50% of coronavirus (COVID-19) cases to be caused by Omicron variant in the next 2 to 4 weeks.

The risk assessment also suggests that Omicron displays a reduction in protection offered by having had a previous infection or vaccination. Whilst there are insufficient data to quantify either vaccine effectiveness or risk of reinfection in the UK exactly, the observed growth, case distribution and early analyses in both South Africa and the UK are consistent with some loss of immune protection against infection. New studies are being undertaken to assess this further.

There is insufficient data to make any assessment of protection against severe disease, or to assess the severity of illness caused by Omicron. Further studies are underway in the UK and abroad.

In addition, UKHSA has published data which shows the detection of cases exhibiting S-gene target failure (SGTF) in recent weeks across the country. Approximately half of PCR tests in the UK are able to detect SGTF.

SGTF is a useful indicator of the presence of Omicron, because as a rule Delta cases have the S-gene and Omicron cases do not. However, it is not confirmatory as there are a number of other reasons that a sample might exhibit SGTF. For example, there are still a small number of cases of other variants, such as Alpha, in the UK which would also result in S-gene dropout or there is a lower amount of virus present in the sample where S-gene dropout cannot be confirmed.

Positive tests with sufficient virus detected from people arriving in the UK are sent for confirmation through Whole Genome Sequencing, regardless of the presence or absence of SGTF.

As part of UKHSA’s routine genomic surveillance, approximately 15 to 20% of all positive PCR tests are also sent for sequencing.

Until the week beginning 23 November 2021, the weekly count of cases with SGTF was routinely less than 150, making up less than 0.1% of all cases. Analyses of sequenced SGTF samples has indicated that until mid-November, more than 99% of these were Delta cases.

In the most recent week of data (specimen dates from 30 November 2021 reported as of 6 December), the number of cases with SGTF has increased to 705. The majority of these cases are located in London and the South East.

Trends in SGTF over and time are however affected by the coverage of laboratories contributing to this surveillance data.

UKHSA Chief Medical Advisor, Dr Susan Hopkins said:

It is increasingly evident that Omicron is highly infectious and there is emerging laboratory and early clinical evidence to suggest that both vaccine-acquired and naturally acquired immunity against infection is reduced for this variant. It is therefore absolutely critical that we all do everything that we can to help break the chains of transmission and slow the spread of this new variant.

Vaccination is critical to help us bolster our defences against becoming severely ill from this new variant – please get your first, second, third or booster jab without delay. Please also make sure to follow all Government guidance to reduce the spread of infection.

It remains vital that anyone with COVID-19 symptoms isolates and gets a PCR test immediately.


You'll find additional data in an 8-page PDF published today called: